Kraft Tape vs Plastic Tape: Which Is Better for Shipping?

Quick answer

For most everyday shipping, kraft paper tape is the better eco-friendly choice because it's recyclable and plastic-free, but plastic tape may still be necessary for heavy or moisture-prone packages.

Why the tape you choose matters

When you're packing a box, the tape you pick affects how easily the box can be recycled and how much plastic ends up in the waste stream. Traditional plastic tape is often overlooked because it's small, but it can contaminate cardboard recycling and contribute to plastic pollution.

Kraft tape, made from reinforced paper, offers a plastic-free alternative that still performs well for many shipping needs. Understanding the trade-offs helps you choose the right tape for your specific package.

Durability and strength: plastic tape holds stronger

Plastic tape, typically polypropylene, is stretchy and adheres aggressively to cardboard, making it very durable during transit. It can withstand rough handling and is less likely to tear under stress.

Kraft tape is strong but not as stretchy. It works well for standard boxes and lightweight items, but for heavy loads or packages that will be tossed around, plastic tape may provide extra security.

Eco-impact: kraft tape is the clear winner

Kraft tape is made from paper, a renewable resource, and is recyclable with the cardboard box. It also breaks down more easily in the environment if it ends up as litter.

Plastic tape is not recyclable and can contaminate cardboard recycling. It also contributes to plastic pollution. For eco-conscious shippers, kraft tape is the obvious choice.

Cost and convenience: plastic tape is often cheaper

Plastic tape is generally less expensive per roll and widely available. It also comes in dispensers that are easy to use.

Kraft tape can be slightly more expensive, but the price difference is often small. It also works with standard tape dispensers, so no special equipment is needed.

Trade-offs at a glance

• Eco-impact: Kraft tape is recyclable and plastic-free; plastic tape is not recyclable and adds to plastic waste. If sustainability is your priority, choose kraft tape.
• Durability: Plastic tape is more stretchy and adheres better to rough surfaces; kraft tape is strong but less flexible. For heavy or fragile items, consider plastic tape or reinforce with extra kraft layers.
• Cost and availability: Plastic tape is usually cheaper and more common; kraft tape is slightly more expensive but still affordable. If budget is tight, plastic tape may be tempting, but the eco benefits of kraft tape often outweigh the small cost difference.

Product spotlight

• Package Free Sustainable Kraft Tape: Package Free Sustainable Kraft Tape is made from kraft paper with a natural rubber adhesive and is approved by the US Postal Service, UPS, and FedEx. This means you can switch to eco-friendly packing tape without worrying about whether it will hold up during shipping.

  

Which tape should you choose?

Best for

• Eco-conscious shippers who want to reduce plastic waste and keep cardboard recyclable
• Lightweight to medium packages that don't require extreme durability
• Businesses and individuals aiming for plastic-free packaging

Not for

• Heavy or oversized packages that need maximum tape strength
• Shipments exposed to moisture or extreme conditions where plastic tape's water resistance is beneficial